Why longevity depends on product type, not just volume
When comparing the 3x Antiperspirant Refill and the Deodorant Cartridge Leaf, the question of "which lasts longer" isn't about one being inherently better. Instead, it's about understanding how each product is designed to be used and how that affects its lifespan in your routine. The key difference lies in what each product is: a liquid antiperspirant refill versus a solid deodorant cartridge.
How each product works and what that means for longevity
The 3x Antiperspirant Refill is a liquid antiperspirant that you apply directly. A single bottle of a liquid antiperspirant can last a long time because you only need a small amount per application. The Deodorant Cartridge Leaf is a solid deodorant stick that you apply directly. A solid stick generally lasts for a certain number of applications, and its lifespan depends on how much product you use each time.
- 3x Antiperspirant Refill: This is a liquid antiperspirant. You apply it by rolling or spraying (depending on the specific product). Because you use a small amount each time, a single bottle can last for many applications, potentially weeks or months. The 3x Antiperspirant Refill is sold as a 3-pack, so you get three times the product, which naturally extends the time between purchases.
- Deodorant Cartridge Leaf: This is a solid deodorant stick. You apply it by swiping it across your underarms. A standard deodorant stick typically lasts for several weeks of daily use, depending on how much you apply. The Deodorant Cartridge Leaf is a refill for your Estrid deodorant case, so you replace the entire stick when it's used up.
The supply factor: subscription and refill design
Both products are designed for subscription delivery, which means you can set a schedule that matches your usage. The 3x Antiperspirant Refill is sold as a 3-pack, so you get three bottles at once. This means you have a larger supply on hand, which can make the product "last longer" in the sense that you don't need to reorder as often. The Deodorant Cartridge Leaf is a single refill, so you'll need to replace it more frequently if you use it daily.
What the catalog confirms about each product
- 3x Antiperspirant Refill: Get 3 liquid antiperspirant refills in the same scent, as often as you need, delivered right to your mailbox. The 3x Antiperspirant Refill is a 3-pack of liquid antiperspirant. This means you get three times the product in one order, which directly extends the time between purchases. It's a volume play for longevity.

3x Antiperspirant Refill - Deodorant Cartridge Leaf: Refill cartridge for your Estrid deodorant case. Simple swap-in design for easy replacement. Helps reduce single-use plastic by reusing your case. The Deodorant Cartridge Leaf is a single solid deodorant refill. Its longevity depends on how often you use it. Its design emphasizes reducing waste by reusing the case, not by packing more product into one order.

Deodorant Cartridge Leaf
How to decide which lasts longer for you
The 3x Antiperspirant Refill will last longer between orders because you receive three bottles at once. If you want to minimize how often you think about reordering, the 3-pack is the clear choice. The Deodorant Cartridge Leaf will need to be replaced more often if you use it daily, but it's a simpler, single-refill system. Your personal usage—how much product you apply and how often—will ultimately determine how many days or weeks each product lasts.
What the catalog doesn't settle
The catalog does not specify the exact number of applications per bottle or cartridge. It doesn't provide a specific number of days or weeks that either product will last. The longevity comparison is based on the product form (liquid vs. solid) and the packaging (single vs. 3-pack). Your individual usage will be the deciding factor.


